From Odin To Beowulf: XENA Goes Valkyrie

Welcome to another Xena Thursday! Today we’re highlighting the infamous Norse trilogy, which, though popular among many fans, has remained decidedly absent from my “best of” list. I’ve decided to organize this post differently; introducing the episodes together upfront and then providing a collective commentary on the trio.

 

01. Season 6, Episode 7: “The Rheingold” (Aired: 11/13/00 | Filmed: 07/10 – 07/18 & 07/31 – 08/01/00)

Xena embarks on a deadly mission involving her dark past when the Norse warrior Beowulf approaches her for help.

Written by R.J. Stewart | Directed by John Fawcett | Production No. V1408

tr204

02. Season 6, Episode 8: “The Ring” (Aired: 11/20/00 | Filmed: 07/19 – 07/28/00)

Xena must battle a monster of her own making to recover the destructive Rheingold ring she forged in her days as an evil warrior.

Written by Joel Metzger | Directed by Rick Jacobson | Production No. V1409

xpc2002_06june_7

03. Season 6, Episode 9: “Return Of The Valkyrie” (Aired: 11/27/00 | Filmed: 08/02 – 08/11/00)

Xena battles to regain her memory and reverse the curse of the Rheingold ring.

Written by Emily Skopov | Directed by John Fawcett | Production No. V1410

xpc2002_05may_6

———————————————————————————————-

I’ll try to be brief. I think, like many sixth season installments, these episodes are flashy, they’re sparkly, they’re pretty, but they’re fundamentally flawed in their storytelling. The overarching problem with this trilogy, as I see it, is that instead of crafting a Xena story in which mythology/history are factored into the plot and influence the characters’ motivations (see “The Ides Of March” and “Antony And Cleopatra,” for instance), this episode takes Norse mythology — or rather, Wagner’s “Ring Cycle” and the Beowulf epic — mashes it all together, and then tries to shoehorn in Xena. As a result, the entire trilogy seems like story for story’s sake, rather than an organic premise that arises naturally from the characters and their actions.

XGgallery0062

Additionally, (and I’m unsure if I’ve discussed this here or not), but I do not like that this series introduced the concept of soulmates into the narrative. Now, I don’t consider myself a “shipper” nor a “subtexter” because, simply, the series (for the most part) didn’t consider itself one or the other. Since the series refused to label itself, I refuse to do the same. There’s evidence within the series to support whatever you like — and that’s part of what makes the storytelling so rich. But when the idea of soulmates is introduced, it almost completely wrecks the conflict between Xena and Gabrielle. If they — and the universe, apparently — seem to think that Xena and Gab are destined to be together, then there’s no opportunity for drama between the two that sees either character walking away. And without that — the fear that Gabrielle might suddenly decide to go back home or that Xena may feel that the violence is too much for Gabrielle and leave her — there’s little tension.

xpc2002_06june_3

Now, I know that many of you might think this is a good thing. After Season Four, Xena and Gabrielle should be at a place where they have both determined to stay together. Or perhaps you’re thinking that the series has outgrown this conflict and no longer needs it. I’m in agreement with you, albeit with one caveat: why does the series itself tell us this? If the characters showed us through their actions, that’s one thing. But when the series tells us, it’s a deliberate removal of suspense. And, truthfully, it removes the human element of the series: the great coincidence that saw Xena and Gabrielle meeting and beginning their travels. If it was ALWAYS meant to happen, than why watch? Soulmates are boring. Real, flawed people who decide to stick together are interesting.

TR-5-wsm

Individually, the three episodes each have their strengths and their weaknesses. The first episode is excellent in setting up a great mystery surrounding another chapter of Xena’s past and the creation of that spiky monster that we saw in the teaser. One thing I found a little incongruous with the rest of the series is that Xena (once again) just leaves Gabrielle behind. It seemed like their relationship was at a point where Xena could just be honest with Gabrielle in regard to her past. The whole thing seems like a story point — get Xena to go with Beowulf (who throughout these episodes is PAINFULLY, and I mean PAINFULLY underdeveloped) while Gabrielle trails them with the help of another hot blonde, Brunnhilda. Still, with R.J. writing this episode, I would say that it’s the most Xena of the three installments. If I WERE to include one episode of the trilogy among my favorites (and I would only do so because of its style and because of some of the finely crafted sequences), it would be “The Rheingold.”

TR-7-wsm

The second episode is basically just a stewing ground until we can get to the final few scenes that set up the conclusion. Like the prior episode, “The Ring” is individually entertaining, but I do have many qualms. My biggest issue is that the rules of the ring are convoluted: the ring bestows its wearer magical powers IF that person has forsaken love. If the wearer hasn’t, the powers last for a very brief time, and then the ring destroys what he/she values most. (It’s the powers lasting for a very short time thing that makes little sense — a.k.a. contrived plot point.) Meanwhile, both Beowulf and Brunnhilda have fallen in love with Gabrielle. Okay… more set-up just to get us to the place where Brunnhilda decides to turn herself into a ring of fire and protect Gabrielle. Yes. Cool concept, but it just feels like a total story manipulation. Meanwhile, Odin and the Valkyries are on hand for more conflict, but I have mixed feelings about his character. He has no redeeming qualities, and his distrust of Xena isn’t as justified as others: Odin, it’s been 35 years; haven’t you heard about her redemption? I wish he was developed more — I’m afraid he’s rather one-dimensional. Fortunately, the episode ends on a nice powerful, dramatic moment that promises an interesting conclusion.   

thering204xpc2002_06june_9

I used to love the third episode when I was younger because of its unique premise. The ring has destroyed Xena’s “sense of self” and now she’s memory-less and about to marry a member of Danish royalty. Beowulf visits her and says that, as Gabrielle’s one true soulmate, only she can pass through Brunnhilda’s fire and wake up the bard with a kiss. One of the things that really takes me out of this episode (and the other two a little bit as well) is how tired Lawless seems — both physically and vocally. Coming right after the grueling “The Abyss,” Xena’s voice is now raspy and breathy. This will continue throughout the entire last season, but it’s especially noticeable and distracting here. Meanwhile, Odin and the Valkyries are after Xena again because, well, they’re still mad about the whole 36-year-old Rheingold affair, (and the episode is in desperate need of villains). So while the episode is more plot-driven than the other two, it’s an effective conclusion to the trilogy — most notably with the Grindl and Grinhilda story, in which the latter makes peace with Xena and with herself.

rotv095

Now that I’ve shared some of my freeform thoughts about the trilogy and the individual episodes, I hope it’s apparent why these episodes have not captured my favor in the way that many other installments have. They’re entertaining (at times), but they’re incredibly flawed, and it’s impossible for me to overlook these episodes’ shortcomings. Essentially, the strengths aren’t quite strong enough to mute the weaknesses. As creative storytelling goes, however, this one is tops.

xenagallery0117

 

 

Come back next Thursday for more Xena! And tune in tomorrow for one more 1935 Film Friday post!

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “From Odin To Beowulf: XENA Goes Valkyrie

  1. You ruined this trilogy for me. I love these three episodes expecially the last two, and the concept of Soulmate for me is important and true to the series. The fact that Xena and Gabrielle are meant to be together doesn’t take away the drama and the tension, on the contrary. These two went through many comflicts and then came back together always. I believe they really love each other in a grander sense, not specifically in a phisical sense. Who believes these two are “just” friends, should look more carefully.

    • Sorry we’re in disagreement. I never said that they were “just friends.” And you’re right, the concept of soulmates is true to the series — especially in Seasons Four and Six.

      But I personally don’t think this was good for the series’ conflict. “Meant to be” is a cliched idea, and it takes away from the pure wonder of Xena and Gabrielle meeting and falling in love coincidentally. Especially since, as Xena always said, we choose our own destiny. If they are soulmates, this makes their love beyond their control — wresting the conflict away from Xena and Gab and putting it on a higher being.

      It’s not good drama to me. It’s trite, and a way to appease the fans after the Rift of Season Three and the Xena/Ares of Season Five.

      But I really appreciate you for reading and commenting! Come back next week, because I’m starting over at the beginning and covering every single episode, sharing not only my thoughts, but the thoughts and memories of the cast and crew.

  2. I feel more or less the same. It’s lovely and the ideas are interesting, but I don’t really care about the Norse characters. For the sympathetic ones, it felt like Brunhilda and Beowulf’s characters becoming driven by Gabrielle was just to prop up the rehash of an early seasons line: “Gabrielle’s shining goodness saves Xena.” It was pretty one-note development, too. Odin bothers me because I watched this trilogy a few weeks or a month after watching the Norse episodes from season five of Hercules. He was a sympathetic character there, so the lack of any such qualities or anything that could be used to connection the two Odins was jarring. I know this came basically two years after those Norse episodes were made and aired, but it still felt weird. Also, yes, his distrust of Xena so many years after she’d become known for her redemption is plot-convenient. If it were just that he’s the grudge-holding type and they’d developed that, then maybe I could understand.

    Speaking as a multishipper: at first I liked the idea of ‘soulmates’–in the sense of ‘always destined to meet,’ especially if that only began in the lives of Xena and Gabrielle during the current timeline because they chose it. (Don’t remember right now if that’s allowed to be the case in canon.) Then season six happened and it just felt tired, like a way to push the romantic aspect of their story without relying on the characters at all. I definitely came away with the impression that they were trying to appease fans who didn’t like anything conceived as a threat to Xena/Gabrielle. In theory I like lesbian Sleeping Beauty, and that at least for once this sort of clichéd romance writing happened with two main female characters instead of a het couple, but. For the most part–while I got much enjoyment from the entire show and appreciate some of the seasons five and six development–most of what I liked about the Xena/Gabrielle relationship, as deep friendship or romance, came from the first four seasons.

    • Hi, tigerpetals! Thanks for reading and commenting.

      My sentiments are the same as yours. It seemed like the relationship was pushed as the focal point of the last season, relegating Xena’s quest for redemption (and Gabrielle’s growth as a warrior) to the sidelines. It wasn’t ignored completely, but the storytelling definitely changed. (And I think this was to appease the fans who found Season Five too lacking in Xena/Gabrielle moments.) But anytime a series deviates from its core premise, I generally have a problem. Additionally, I feel like what was good and natural and exciting about the Xena/Gabrielle bond was exploited and cheapened (and forced) in the last year. They were trying too hard, and the series suffered as a result. This trio of episodes is the perfect example. Pretty packaging, empty inside.

  3. Pingback: THE XENA SCROLLS: An Opinionated Episode Guide (607 & 608) | THAT'S ENTERTAINMENT!

  4. Pingback: THE XENA SCROLLS: An Opinionated Episode Guide (609 & 610) | THAT'S ENTERTAINMENT!

  5. Pingback: Following XENA: The Relationship (IV) | THAT'S ENTERTAINMENT!

  6. Pingback: Following XENA: The Sins of Her Past (VI) | THAT'S ENTERTAINMENT!

Leave a Reply