Sing For Your Supper: Dick and Larry in the ’30s (III)

Welcome to a new Musical Theatre Monday and the continuation of our six week series on the yet-to-be covered ’30s scores of Richard Rodgers and Lorenz Hart, whose work from both the ’20s and ’40s has been well represented here. The only featured shows of theirs from the ’30s — my favorite musical decade — have been Ever Green (1930), Jumbo (1935), On Your Toes (1936), and Too Many Girls (1939). So we still have some rich area to cover! So far in this series, we’ve highlighted Simple Simon (1930) and America’s Sweetheart (1931). Today . . .


III. Babes In Arms (04/14/37 – 12/18/37)


This score is better known than the show, for Babes In Arms is among a handful of ’30s musicals in which over half the tunestack consists of classics that have since become part of the Great American Songbook. But it’s easy to overlook the fact that while many people will recognize most of these songs, the show is almost as esoteric as the others we’ve covered this month. The story, with a book written by Rodgers and Hart, concerns a group of Long Island teens whose parents are off performing. In order to avoid being sent to a work farm, they decide to put on a show. Unfortunately, although the show is an artistic success, they are sent off to the country — where a French aviator comes to their rescue. Through all of this, there are some romantic pairings. What made the show unique was that it actually cast teens and up-and-coming young performers: Mitzi Green, Ray Heatherton, Wynn Murray, Duke McHale, and the Nicholas Brothers. Other cast members include Alfred Drake, Rolly Pickert, Grace McDonald, and, in the ensemble, Dan Dailey. As with On Your Toes, this production also saw George Balanchine earning distinction for his choreography, which included a memorable dream ballet.

A film version was made in 1939 with Judy Garland and Mickey Rooney, but only two of the songs from the score were used (another case of stupid Hollywood decision making). A revision from the ’50s, which drastically changed the book — removing all elements of ’30s politics, including a potentially insensitive dance number for the Nicholas brothers, “All Dark People (Is Light On Their Feet)” — has been licensed and performed for decades. Thankfully, the original version of Babes In Arms has been resurrected on occasion and actually been recorded twice in near full: once by New World Records (following a 1989 concert) and the other with the cast of the 1999 Encores! production. The former is much better. Nothing, however, beats original cast member performances! Above is the very talented Mitzi Green with a brief rendition of a future Sinatra classic, “The Lady Is A Tramp,” which she introduced, of course. It is taken from a live radio performance years later.

Perhaps the most well known tune from the score (although this is certainly debatable) is Green’s “My Funny Valentine,” which she sings in honor of Heatherton as her love interest, whose name is Valentine. The rendition above is an instrumental one by Edgar Fairchild and Adam Carroll, who were in the original production’s orchestra.

Another original cast performance; above is the ever delightful Wynn Murray with “Johnny One-Note.” This rendition was recorded in studio. (For access to a live radio performance by Murray of the same number, subscribe and comment below!)

Among my favorite Rodgers and Hart tunes is “I Wish I Were In Love Again,” another one of their all time standards. The rendition above is by Rooney and Garland — not from the ’39 Babes In Arms, but from Words And Music (1948).

From the New World Records recording mentioned above, here are two lesser known R&H classics, “Imagine” (above) and “All At Once” (below).

And we’ll close today’s post with my pick for the score’s most haunting, the young lovers’ “Where Or When,” performed by original cast member Ray Heatherton below.



Come back next Monday for another Rodgers and Hart musical! And tune in tomorrow for the best from the third season of The Jeffersons!

3 thoughts on “Sing For Your Supper: Dick and Larry in the ’30s (III)

  1. Dear Jackson, I’ve been browsing your site trying to find the answer to a pressing question. In January 2014 you posted to YouTube the Kern/Wodehouse song Where Do All the Good Songs Go. This is a superb rendition but you haven’t said who the singer is. I played it as part of a presentation I gave last week on the centenary of the coming together of Bolton-Wodehouse-Kern (the trio of musical fame) and now my friends and I are driving ourselves mad trying to guess who the singer might be. Can you put us out of our misery please? By the way, love your work. Cheers.

    • Hi, Noel! Thanks for reading and commenting.

      The singer is Andrea Marcovicci and the album is EARLY KERN. Buy it here:

      Stay tuned for more Kern this December as we explore some of his forgotten post Princess Theatre scores of the ’20s . . . and then sometime in the future (late 2016/early 2017) when we go back to the decade before and trace his musical origins!

      • Many thanks. You have prevented grave mental agitation and allowed me to enjoy your Kern retrospective. Cheers

Comments are closed.